Dissertations

Monday, 2 November, 2026

Aizhamal Rakhmetova: Essays in Applied Economics

Komise pro obhajobu:

Daniel Műnich (CERGE-EI, chair)
Julie Chytilová (CERGE-EI and IES)
Dana Hamplová (Institute of Sociology, Czech Academy of Sciences)


Vedení práce:

Andreas Menzel (University of Padova)
Sebastian Ottinger (CERGE-EI)
Christian Ochsner (CERGE-EI)


Oponenti:
Marc Witte (VU Amsterdam)
Jonathan Conning (Hunter College, CUNY)


https://cerge-ei.webex.com/cerge-ei/j.php?MTID=m159a8be16d76ae78bf9a2e5b8423fded
Meeting number: 2746 035 5456
Meeting password: 362145

Abstract:

This dissertation contains three essays in applied economics on how external shocks affect vulnerable individuals and households when economic, institutional, and social constraints limit their ability to adjust. The chapters study three different settings: abortion restrictions and mortgage credit in the United States, environmental shocks and migration in Indonesia, and weather shocks and bride kidnapping in Kyrgyzstan. A common theme across the dissertation is that shocks have distributional consequences that depend on pre-existing constraints, including credit constraints, liquidity constraints, gendered institutions, and social norms.

The first chapter examines whether post-Dobbs abortion restrictions affected gender gaps in mortgage credit. Using HMDA data for 2018-2024 and a borrower-level triple-difference design, I find that abortion bans increased the female--male mortgage denial gap by approximately 0.9 percentage points. The results are consistent with a tightening at the approval margin: female applicants become more likely to be denied relative to male applicants, originations decline, and interest rates among originated loans fall modestly, suggesting selection among approved borrowers.

The second chapter studies whether financial resources change migration responses to environmental stress among poor households in Indonesia. Combining the Indonesian Family Life Survey with climate data, natural-disaster information, and variation in cash-transfer programs, the chapter shows that financial resources can both reduce and increase migration. Cash transfers reduce migration after short-term rainfall shocks and natural disasters, consistent with adaptation in place, but increase migration after persistent rainfall shocks and temperature anomalies, consistent with the relaxation of liquidity constraints.

The third chapter studies whether climate shocks affect harmful marriage practices and related social norms. Using the Life in Kyrgyzstan Survey and monthly weather data, the chapter shows that dry winters increase the probability of bride kidnapping and make attitudes toward the practice more favorable. The effects on attitudes are stronger among lower-income households, suggesting that economic vulnerability can amplify the effect of climate shocks on gendered social norms.

Overall, the dissertation shows that policy and environmental shocks do not affect all individuals equally. Their effects depend on the constraints people face and on the institutions through which economic and social decisions are made. By studying credit access, migration, and marriage practices, the dissertation contributes to understanding how shocks translate into inequality, vulnerability, and changes in economic behavior.

Full Text: "Essays in Applied Economics"